Search Site
IBC Centre, 130 East Travis Street, Suite #425 | San Antonio, TX 78205

Lawsuit Challenging Harris County Felony Bail System Can Proceed to Trial

A federal judge has decided that a lawsuit challenging the Harris County felony bail system should continue to trial. The federal class action was brought by the same legal team that successfully challenged the county’s misdemeanor bail practices last year, resulting in a settlement that allows most defendants facing misdemeanor charges to be released without bail.

The plaintiffs’ team, comprised of Washington, D.C.-based Civil Rights Corps, the Texas Civil Rights Project and Houston law firm Susman Godfrey, is hoping to build on the systematic bail reforms started by the misdemeanor case. The current lawsuit, Russell v. Harris County, seeks a similar overhaul of the felony bail system. The plaintiffs — thousands of indigent arrestees detained pretrial due to unaffordable bail — argue that the system unconstitutionally discriminates against poorer defendants. The crux of the suit is that the right to pretrial release should not depend on financial means.

The defendants in the suit include all 23 Harris County felony district judges, 19 of whom oppose the lawsuit and are represented by Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton. The four who approve of the litigation have retained attorney Allan Van Fleet, who also represented the judges in the misdemeanor bail reform case.

In early October 2020, the judges represented by Paxton filed a motion to dismiss the federal suit on grounds of judicial immunity, lack of federal jurisdiction and lack of standing to sue. In a 65-page opinion denying the motion, Chief U.S. District Judge Lee H. Rosenthal determined that jurisdiction was established because bail determinations implicate federally protected rights and that as a group, the prisoners have standing to sue, even though the individual plaintiffs would change over time as prisoners are released or transferred and new ones are jailed. Rosenthal further found that the case involves “vigorously disputed factual allegations that must be developed further to resolve the legal issues,” Including whether the judicial immunity defense should prevail.

Paxton’s clients are appealing the decision to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit. Because the opinion focused solely on procedural issues, the appeals court won’t deal with the case’s substantive merits, namely, whether the felony bail system is unconstitutionally discriminatory.

At the Law Offices of Kevin Collins in San Antonio, Texas, we are defense attorneys with experience navigating the bail system and with a track record of securing our clients’ release on bail or on recognizance. If you’ve been arrested and want a staunch advocate to protect your rights, call 210-598-8629 or contact us online for a consultation.

COVID-19 Notice
We are here to help and support you through these generally challenging times with your specific legal issues. You will be able to reach me or my staff through our main telephone numbers, and of course by email: [email protected] Phone conferences for existing and potential clients are available, as is the video conference feature through the Zoom app. Zoom may present some privacy challenges so phone conferences are preferred. Please take care of your health by following the measures recommended by the CDC, and by state and local authorities.
Firm Recognition
  • Super Lawyers
  • Best Law Firms 2021
  • Three Best Rated
  • ThreeBest Rated
Client Reviews
  • google

    Kevin Collins is by far the best man for the job. Almost immediately as I talk to him on the phon I felt calm and reassuring. He started the process and handled it, very efficient and got the job done. He also responds to my calls very quickly and ke...

    Read more

    Aretha Jones

  • google

    Fast and quick response ..That's how he acted ..Good professional service ..will call him again definitely if we need help.. Sincerely J VELA

    Read more

    Juan Vela

  • google

    Best lawyer I’ve ever had!

    Read more

    Germ Eee

  • yelp

    My family was in need of a lawyer and we reached out to A lawyer we knew who referred us to Mr. Collins. Mr. Collins did an EXCELLENT job defending our family member. Everything he did was extremely top-notch and very professional and he kept us info...

    Read more

    Shaun P.

  • google

    The best attorney I’ve ever had mr. Collins has represented me in more than one case and both times he has got the charges dismissed definitely worth every penny And above all that a man of his word

    Read more

    James Cooper

See all reviews
Case Results
State of Texas v. J.T. Furnishing Alcohol to a minor dismissed after start of trial despite death caused by accident
View All
Contact us

Quick Contact Form